Best Car Insurance Comparison Sites in 2025 (Your Guide to the Top 10 Sites)

NerdWallet, Insurify, and EverQuote stand out as the best car insurance comparison sites for finding fast, reliable quotes across the best auto insurance companies.

Our Top 10 Picks: Best Car Insurance Comparison Sites

We evaluated each platform based on traffic, user satisfaction, quote accuracy, and overall value, and these trusted tools make it easy to shop rates and save on auto insurance in just minutes.

While we excluded AutoInsurance.org to keep the rankings unbiased, it’s still the most efficient and accurate site for comparing auto insurance quotes. Use our free quote comparison tool to find the top providers in your area.

#1 – NerdWallet

Pros

• Huge Audience: NerdWallet has over 10 million monthly users, a strong Domain Authority (DA) of 81, and a Global Rank of 1.4K, making it the most authoritative site on this list.
• Helpful Tools: NerdWallet includes budget calculators, financial guides, and side-by-side insurance quote comparisons to help users understand what they’re buying.
• Multi-Product Search: You can use NerdWallet sites to compare car insurance, credit cards, loans, and more, all in one place. Get more insights in our NerdWallet review.

Cons

• Average Reviews: NerdWallet sites have a 3.7 out of 5 rating, showing that while helpful, some users may not be fully satisfied.
• Less Insurance Focused: These sites cover many topics, so you might have to dig through financial content to get to insurance tools.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#2 – Insurify

Pros

• Strong Traffic: Insurify attracts 2.6 million users monthly, holds a DA of 59, and has a Global Rank of 15.4K, showing steady growth in the insurance space.
• Excellent Ratings: With a 4.8 out of 5 customer score, users rate Insurify sites as one of the easiest and most reliable ways to get quotes.
• Smart Technology: Insurify uses AI to match users to real-time quotes, often in less than two minutes. Check out our Insurify auto insurance review to learn more.

Cons

• Smaller Reach: This site gets less traffic than NerdWallet or EverQuote, so fewer users may sometimes mean fewer carriers.
• Not All Providers: Some big insurance companies may not appear on Insurify sites depending on your location.

#3 – EverQuote

Pros

• Big Visitor Numbers: EverQuote draws 3.2 million monthly users, with a DA of 65 and Global Rank of 17.9K, making it one of the busiest insurance lead platforms.
• Many Options: It connects users to a large network of carriers, increasing the chance of finding a low rate (Read More: Where can I compare online auto insurance companies?).
• Quick Form Process: You can fill out basic vehicle information and get redirected to quotes quickly without a lot of extra questions.

Cons

• Very Low Ratings: EverQuote sites have a 1.3 out of 5 rating, with many users complaining about excessive emails and calls.
• Lead Selling Issues: After using these sites, you may get contacted by multiple third-party agents even if you don’t sign up.

#4 – The Zebra

Pros

• Steady Traffic: With 1.5 million monthly users, a DA of 62, and a Global Rank of 28.6K, The Zebra is one of the most recognizable names in auto insurance comparison.
• Modern Layout: It’s known for its clean UI design and mobile-friendly tools, making it easy to compare auto insurance online.
• Highly Rated: According to The Zebra insurance review, customers rate the site at 4.5 out of 5, showing that most users are happy with their experience.

Cons

• Fewer Filters: The Zebra sites offer fewer customization options than some competitors when comparing quotes.
• Auto Only Focus: The Zebra is best for auto insurance comparison, but limited for renters, home, or life insurance.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#5 – QuoteWizard

Pros

• Strong Monthly Reach: QuoteWizard brings in 1.8 million monthly users, with a DA of 56 and a Global Rank of 32.5K, making it a well-known name in the comparison space.
• Great Ratings: With a 4.7 out of 5 score, users praise it for giving accurate quotes for all types of vehicles. Compare auto insurance rates by vehicle make and model for more.
• Wide Carrier Access: QuoteWizard sites partner with many national and local insurers, giving users plenty of auto insurance options.

Cons

• Too Many Ads: Many users experience heavy advertising on the site, which can slow down or distract from the quote process.
• Data Sharing: QuoteWizard may share your personal information with multiple agents, leading to follow-up calls or emails.

#6 – SmartFinancial

Pros

• Over a Million Users: With 1.1 million monthly users, a DA of 39, and a Global Rank of 39.6K, SmartFinancial remains a mid-sized player with consistent user flow.
• Real-Time Quotes: Uses live quote technology to match you with local providers almost instantly (Read More: How to Find Auto Insurance Agents in Your Area).
• Easy to Use: The layout is simple, direct, and mobile-friendly, which is good for users who want quick results when comparing car insurance online.

Cons

• Low Customer Score: SmartFinancial has a 1.6 out of 5 rating, with complaints about calls and limited options.
• Less In-Depth Info: These sites focus more on speed than education, so there may be fewer helpful guides.

#7 – Compare.com

Pros

• Transparent Quotes: The platform shows side-by-side pricing, so you can easily see which carrier offers the best deal (Read More: Where to Compare Auto Insurance Rates)
• High User Score: With a 4.6 out of 5 rating from shoppers, Compare.com is seen as a trustworthy source for accurate car insurance quotes.
• Plenty of Resources: Compare.com offers guides on policy types and state laws and provides helpful pop-ups that explain coverage during the quote process.

Cons

• Smaller Audience: With 370,000 monthly users, Compare.com has fewer users than others, meaning fewer partner carriers in some areas.
• Fewer Extras: Compare.com focuses on basics, so you won’t find many articles or tools for learning about auto insurance coverage.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#8 – Policygenius

Pros

• Steady User Base: Policygenius attracts around 440,000 monthly users, with a DA of 70 and Global Rank of 130K, signaling strong online trust.
• High Ratings: With a 4.7 out of 5 score, users love the clean design and smart layout.
• Multi-Product Search: You can compare car, home, renters, and life insurance in one place. Get more details on how to get multiple auto insurance quotes.

Cons

• Not Car-Specific: These sites cover many insurance types, so auto quotes may take extra clicks to find.
• Extra Navigation Needed: First-time users may have to go through additional steps before seeing cheap car insurance quotes.

#9 – MoneyGeek

Pros

• Detailed Advice: These sites include state-by-state guides, cost breakdowns, and driver-specific tips (Read More: How long does it take to compare auto insurance quotes?).
• Solid Ratings: With a 4.0 out of 5 score, most users are satisfied with MoneyGeek auto insurance quotes.
• New Buyers: MoneyGeek’s streamlined quote comparison is easy to navigate for new drivers and first-time auto insurance buyers.

Cons

• Longer Forms: Getting quotes takes more time because the sites ask for detailed personal info up front.
• Fewer Quote Matches: You may see fewer companies listed than on bigger comparison sites like NerdWallet or The Zebra.

#10 – Gabi

Pros

• Auto-Scan Feature: Gabi sites can analyze your current policy and compare it to others with almost no personal information (Learn more: How to Get an Auto Insurance Quote Without a Car).
• Average Ratings: A 3.5 out of 5 score shows decent customer satisfaction for basic car insurance quote comparisons.
• Parent Company: In 2022, Gabi was acquired by Experian, a credit bureau, providing users with more accurate car insurance quotes.

Cons

• Limited Choices: Gabi sites may only show one or two quotes, depending on your location or driving record.
• Less Transparency: Some users say it’s not clear which insurers are providing the quotes on Gabi auto insurance comparison sites.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

How Top Comparison Sites Help You Compare Quotes

It’s important to look at each site’s trust score, domain authority, global traffic rank, and how long they’ve been around. These factors help show how reliable and established a website is when it comes to comparing auto insurance quotes.

The best auto insurance comparison sites don’t just help you save — they make it easier to get quotes from top insurers in one place. But each site works a little differently. Some show quotes on the site, while others redirect you or send your information to agents (Read More: How to Get an Auto Insurance Quote Without Giving Personal Information).

Below, we break down how NerdWallet, Insurify, and EverQuote help you compare quotes and how these top car insurance comparison sites rank based on trust, online authority, and user reach.

NerdWallet

NerdWallet was founded in 2009 and has a very high trust score and is widely respected as a financial resource. With a domain authority of 81 and a global rank of 1,400, it’s one of the most visited personal finance websites. While it covers everything from credit cards to investing, it’s recognized by users as a trusted and unbiased authority in auto insurance.

NerdWallet helps drivers compare insurance by guiding them through a step-by-step quote process. To get started, you’ll enter your ZIP code, vehicle details, age, and basic driver information, including your driving record and insurance history.

Unlike dedicated insurance comparison platforms, NerdWallet typically redirects users to insurer websites to complete the quote. This means you won’t always see prices directly on NerdWallet’s site. It’s a helpful tool if you’re researching providers and reading advice, but it’s less efficient for side-by-side quote comparisons.

Learn More: How to Choose an Auto Insurance Company

Insurify

Insurify was launched in 2013 and has earned a high trust score thanks to its quote accuracy and privacy-friendly design. It holds a domain authority of 59 and a global rank of 15,400, placing it among the most popular insurance-specific comparison tools.

Insurify is designed specifically for users to get free online auto insurance quotes. Provide ZIP code, age, driving history, coverage preferences, and vehicle information, including make and model.

You’ll also need to enter an email address, but no phone number is required. Within minutes, Insurify displays real-time quotes directly on the site from top insurers, allowing users to compare prices and coverage in a clean, side-by-side layout without being redirected.

EverQuote

EverQuote has a high trust score, a domain authority of 65, and a global rank of 17,900. While it maintains strong web visibility and high traffic, its business model leans more toward lead generation than full-service quote comparison. That’s why it’s better suited for users looking for a car insurance agent and who prefer personal assistance over instant quote results.

EverQuote collects your ZIP code, vehicle and driver information, and coverage preferences. Unlike Insurify, you must enter both your email and phone number, which are then shared with agents and insurance partners.

Instead of showing prices directly on the site, EverQuote typically redirects users to external websites or prompts follow-up contact from providers. As a result, many users experience frequent calls or emails after using the platform, and direct quote comparison is limited.

Read More: How to Evaluate Auto Insurance Quotes

What Customers Say About Auto Insurance Comparison Sites

Many drivers have shared their experiences using the best car insurance comparison sites, and reviews show what works well and what doesn’t.

NerdWallet has a 3.7 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot. Users appreciate its comprehensive financial tools and resources. However, some mention that obtaining auto insurance quotes can involve multiple steps, making the process less streamlined compared to more specialized platforms.

Insurify is one of the top-rated options, with a 4.8 out of 5 score. People like that it’s easy to use, gives fast results, and doesn’t flood them with spam calls or emails. Some Reddit users say Insurify gave them real quotes from top insurance companies in just a few minutes.

The Zebra also has great reviews, earning a 4.5 out of 5. Users like its clean layout and how simple it is to see quotes side-by-side. Even first-time shoppers say it’s easy to understand. Policygenius and Compare.com also do well with users who want to bundle car and home insurance, and they offer helpful tips while you shop.

On the other hand, EverQuote gets a low 1.3 out of 5 rating, and many people complain about getting too many phone calls after using the site. SmartFinancial has similar problems, with a 1.6 rating and reports of limited quote options and follow-ups from salespeople.

Read More: How to Find Affordable Auto Insurance Rates Online

Why Uninsured Rates Matter When Using Comparison Sites

Car insurance comparison sites are especially valuable in states with high uninsured motorist rates, where choosing the right coverage is critical. If you live in one of the states below, you pay more for auto insurance to account for the risk of uninsured drivers.

Washington, D.C. leads with more than 25% of drivers uninsured, followed by New Mexico and Mississippi. Even states like Michigan and Tennessee show significant risk. Start comparing the best uninsured and underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage to find affordable coverage.

By using car insurance comparison sites, drivers in these areas can easily find policies that include uninsured motorist protection and compare prices across multiple providers to get the best deal.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

How Often People Shop Around for Auto Insurance

Many drivers turn to the best car insurance comparison sites to shop for affordable coverage, but how often they do varies by age group. Millennials are the most active, with 20% using comparison sites every year to find better rates.

While some drivers revisit their options every 2–3 years, others rarely or never compare quotes — only 18% of Baby Boomers, 15% of Gen Z, and only 12% of Gen X.

Why is it so hard to find cheap auto insurance? You could be paying too much for car insurance if you aren’t comparing quotes online. Using the best auto insurance comparison sites regularly can help drivers avoid overpaying and ensure they get the best coverage.

We didn’t include AutoInsurance.org in the rankings to stay fair, but it’s often praised for giving accurate quotes quickly without sending your personal information to third parties. Many drivers say it’s the easiest and most reliable way to compare auto insurance quotes online. Enter your ZIP code to compare rates from the top providers near you.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption