Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Review for 2025 (Uncover Rates and Discounts Here)

Alfa Mutual auto insurance reviews are usually positive, with most drivers agreeing that this company provides top-notch service.

While it’s not one of the cheapest auto insurance companies on the market, Alfa Insurance Company makes up for it by including more coverage in its policies than other providers.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Review

However, you can only buy Alfa Mutual auto insurance in Mississippi, Alabama, and Georgia.

Read on to learn more about insurance from Alfa Mutual, including how much it costs and what’s included in the policies. Then, enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool to find the best prices in your area.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Rates

While it has a reputation for excellence in customer service and coverage options, Alfa auto insurance rates are on the higher side. Take a look below to get an idea of how much you might pay for coverage.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Age, Gender, & Coverage Level

As you can see, Alfa rates can be expensive, particularly if you’re looking for the best auto insurance for teen drivers. However, there are many factors that affect auto insurance rates beyond your age and gender.

One of the most important is your driving record. Drivers with things like speeding tickets, DUIs, and at-fault accidents can pay double what someone with a clean record pays. You can check Alfa’s rates by driving record below.

Alfa Mutual auto insurance quotes are a bit on the high side, especially if you’re a high-risk driver looking for the cheapest coverage possible.

Although Alfa Mutual car insurance rates are usually on the pricier side, it often outperforms larger, cheaper companies in areas like customer service. You should still compare quotes with multiple companies to see how Alfa Insurance compares to local competitors.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Costs vs. The Competition

Many drivers consider Alfa to be one of the best Alabama auto insurance companies. To see how Alfa Mutual compares to some of the top providers in the country, check the rates below.

Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Provider & Coverage Level

Alfa Insurance certainly isn’t the cheapest option on the market. When you need the cheapest auto insurance possible, you may need to look at providers like Progressive or USAA instead. It’s always important to compare rates with multiple companies. If you don’t, you’ll likely overpay for your coverage.

Luckily, comparing rates is easy — you only need a personalized quote. Most insurance providers make getting a quote easy if you use their website, Alfa Mutual included.

Repeat the process a few times until you have enough quotes to compare. Alternatively, you can enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool to see rates from multiple companies at once. Using a free comparison tool is a great way to save time, rather than having to wonder, “Where is an Alfa Insurance near me?”

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Options

Like most insurance providers, Alfa auto insurance quotes can include all the basic types of coverage. These include:

• Liability: Liability insurance pays for damage you cause in an at-fault accident. It covers property damage and injuries, but it doesn’t cover your vehicle.
• Medical Payments: Medical payments coverage (MedPay) handles health care costs for you and your passengers after an accident, no matter who caused the collision.
• Collision: If you want help with your vehicle repairs after an accident, you need collision insurance. Collision insurance coverage helps pay for your repairs no matter who was at fault for an accident.
• Comprehensive: Comprehensive auto insurance pays for your car repairs after unexpected events. That includes damage from fires, floods, animals, falling objects, and theft.
• Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist: Although all the states Alfa operates in require insurance, not everyone follows the law. Uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance protects you from drivers with inadequate coverage.

Alfa extends more coverage than expected with these basic types of insurance. For example, your liability insurance will pay anyone Alfa requests at a trial regarding an accident you caused $50 per day they miss work.

Whether you want just enough insurance to meet the requirements in your state or a full coverage policy, you can get a policy that matches your needs with Alfa.

Most customers recommend getting an Alfa Insurance full coverage policy to get the most out of your coverage. If you want to customize your policy with additional coverage, Alfa sells a few add-ons. It may not offer the longest list of add-ons, but there’s plenty of value to be found.

Alfa Auto Insurance Add-On Options

While it doesn’t have the longest list of add-ons, Alfa offers a variety of customization options. Part of Alfa Perks includes the option to add the following add-ons to your policy at an affordable price:

• Roadside Assistance: If you’re stuck with a flat tire, dead battery, or empty tank of gas, Alfa will come to the rescue with one of the best roadside assistance plans in the area.
• Accidental Death and Dismemberment: Add this to your policy to get extra coverage in case you’re killed, dismembered, or blinded in a collision.
• Loss of Income: This coverage pays up to $750 per month for a year after an accident leaves you unable to work.
• Loss of Use: When your vehicle is in the mechanic shop after a covered accident, Alfa will cover up to $100 a day for a rental.

It’s not the longest list of add-ons, but Alfa does provide some unique coverages that can be hard to find elsewhere. For example, finding a policy that covers a year’s worth of lost wages is rare outside of Alfa.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Discounts

The Alfa Corporation offers a few ways to help its customers save, including several ways that appeal to its local driver base. While it’s not the longest list of auto insurance discounts, you can save with the following Alfa Mutual car insurance discounts:

Alfa Auto Insurance Discounts by Savings Potential

These few discounts might not be able to help every driver. With Alfa’s rates already a bit on the high side, this provider may not be the best choice if you’re on a tight budget. If you do qualify for these discounts, however, they can be very helpful. For example, Alfa homeowners insurance reviews report decent savings for bundling policies.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Customer Reviews

When it comes to service, customers rely on the promise of the Alfa Difference. Alfa is committed to providing the best service possible. Most customers leave positive Alfa Mutual car insurance reviews, but there are concerns about the pricing, as you can see in this Reddit user’s post about Alfa Insurance.

Car insurance Question: Afla vs the rest
byu/PinkSnowBirdie inHuntsvilleAlabama

As you can see from this Reddit user’s experience, Alfa is generally accepted as costing more. However, most Reddit users responding in the comments agree that Alfa is one of the best auto insurance companies to work with.

In particular, the Alfa Mutual auto insurance claims process receives excellent reviews. Most customers agree that Alfa representatives go above and beyond to help their customers.

Alfa Insurance makes it easy to get help filing a claim in any situation. As suggested above, you can use the Alfa website or mobile app to start a claim. You can also call the Alfa Mutual auto insurance phone number for help if you’d rather speak with a representative.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Business Reviews

Aside from looking at customer reviews, you should also look at third-party rating companies. These companies provide valuable insights into how well an insurance provider actually performs.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Business Ratings & Consumer Reviews

BBB Alfa insurance reviews also suggest that Alfa is one of the best companies for paying auto insurance claims in the states it operates in.

In spite of being a smaller company, Alfa Insurance ratings are relatively high. For example, its A.M. Best rating of A means you can trust Alfa to pay your future claims because it is a financially secure company.

Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance Pros and Cons

Before you purchase a policy, you can always go over the pros and cons of a company. While it won’t give you a definitive answer on whether a company is right for you, it can certainly rule a provider out. For starters, here are the benefits you’ll have to look forward to when you shop at Alfa Mutual:

• Excellent Service: Many Alfa auto insurance customers are impressed with how the company goes above and beyond expectations.
• Online Options: You can get online quotes, and if you register your MyAlfa account, you can use the Alfa2Go app to manage your policy.
• Generous Discounts: Alfa offers several ways to help its customers save, including a good student auto insurance discount.

Like all other insurance companies, Alfa Mutual is not without its drawbacks. Before you sign up for an Alfa policy, you should be aware of the following drawbacks:

• Limited Availablity: You can only purchase an Alfa policy if you live in Alabama, Georgia, or Mississippi.
• Higher Rates: Alfa Mutual car insurance quotes are usually a bit higher than the national average.

These pros and cons can give you a better idea if Alfa Insurance is right for you, especially if pricing is the most important aspect of your search for coverage.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

See if Alfa Mutual Auto Insurance is Right for You

Insurance through Alfa may cost more, but most customer Alfa Mutual auto insurance reviews agree that the excellent service is worth the price. Alfa Insurance aims to give its customers better service than expected, and that’s reflected in its excellent coverage options.

While Alfa may be a great choice for your auto insurance needs, you should still learn how to evaluate auto insurance quotes with other companies. You can get started today by entering your ZIP code into our free comparison tool.