Best Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance in 2024 (Check Out the Top 10 Companies)

Finding the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance which requires balancing affordability, coverage options, and customer service. State Farm, USAA, and Progressive lead the market with rates starting at $60 per month, offering robust coverage and reliable claims handling.

Whether you’re prioritizing budget-friendly premiums or comprehensive protection, these top providers stand out as the best choices for Milwaukee drivers.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance

Finding cheapest auto insurance in Milwaukee can seem like a difficult task, but all of the information you need is right here. We’ll cover factors that affect auto insurance rates in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, including driving record, credit, commute time, and more. Enter your ZIP code above to get free Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance quotes.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#1 – State Farm: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Wide Network of Agents: State Farm’s extensive network of agents ensures personalized service and easy access to local support, making it a strong contender for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance. This local presence provides peace of mind and quick resolutions to any issues that may arise.
• Holistic Coverage Alternatives: Offering a wide range of coverage options, including liability, collision, and comprehensive, State Farm is ideal for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance. Their customizable plans help meet various needs and preferences.
• Clean Record Discounts: State Farm offers numerous discounts for safe driving habits and technology use, such as their Drive Safe & Save program. This can significantly lower premiums for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance. See more specifics in our State Farm review.

Cons

• Higher Premiums for Younger Drivers: Younger drivers may face higher premiums with State Farm compared to other providers. This can be a drawback for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance on a tighter budget.
• Customer Service Issues: Some customers report issues with customer service, such as delayed responses or complicated claims processes, which may affect the overall experience of securing the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

#2 – USAA: Best for Military Benefits

Pros

• Exclusive Military Benefits: USAA is renowned for offering exceptional benefits and discounts to military personnel and their families, making it the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance for those with military ties. Their tailored coverage options address specific needs unique to military families.
• Top-Rated Client Satisfaction: USAA consistently receives high marks for customer satisfaction and service quality, ensuring a positive experience when dealing with claims and policy management, which contributes to it being the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Member Benefit Pricing: USAA provides highly competitive rates and discounts, especially for its members, helping them secure the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance at an affordable price. Discover our USAA review for a full list.

Cons

• Eligibility Restrictions: USAA coverage is only available to military members, veterans, and their families, which limits its availability for other potential customers looking for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Limited Local Presence: USAA’s local presence is not as extensive as some competitors, potentially affecting in-person service and support for those who prefer face-to-face interactions when securing the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

#3 – Progressive: Best for Competitive Rates

Pros

• Adaptable Policy Options: Progressive offers a range of customizable insurance policies, including usage-based and pay-per-mile options, which can be ideal for drivers seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance tailored to their specific needs.
• Drive Analysis Program: The Snapshot program allows policyholders to earn discounts based on their driving habits, providing an opportunity for significant savings on the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance for safe drivers. Find additional information in our Progressive auto insurance review.
• Effective Online Platforms: Progressive’s user-friendly online tools and mobile app make managing policies and filing claims straightforward and efficient, enhancing the overall experience for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Cons

• Varied Customer Service Quality: Customer service experiences with Progressive can vary widely, with some reporting challenges in getting timely and effective support, which might impact those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Complex Policy Details: Progressive’s extensive range of coverage options can sometimes lead to complex policy details that may be challenging to navigate, potentially causing confusion for those seeking straightforward solutions for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#4 – Allstate: Best for Comprehensive Coverages

Pros

• Full-Spectrum Insurance Options: Allstate offers a broad array of coverage options, including identity theft protection and new car replacement, making it a strong contender for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance with extensive protection features.
• Many Discount Opportunities: As mentioned in our Allstate auto insurance review, Allstate provides numerous discount opportunities, such as bundling multiple policies and safe driving discounts, helping drivers save on the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Superior Service Ratings: With a wide network of local agents, Allstate offers personalized support and tailored advice, enhancing the overall experience for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Cons

• Higher Average Rates: Allstate’s average rates can be higher compared to some competitors, which may not be ideal for drivers specifically looking for the most budget-friendly option for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Claims Processing Delays: Some customers have reported delays in the claims processing time with Allstate, which could impact the experience of those relying on prompt support for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

#5 – Farmers: Best for Flexible Policies

Pros

• Bespoke Insurance Policies: Farmers offers a variety of flexible policy options, including customizable coverage levels and endorsements, making it a versatile choice for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance tailored to individual needs.
• Aggregate Policy Discounts: Farmers provides significant savings for bundling multiple insurance policies, such as home and auto, which can be advantageous for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance at a reduced cost. Explore further details in our review of Farmers.
• Innovative Coverage Add-Ons: Farmers offers unique coverage add-ons like ride-share insurance and accident forgiveness, enhancing the overall protection and value of their policies, making them a standout option for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Cons

• Higher Rates for Young Drivers: Farmers’ rates for younger drivers may be higher compared to some other insurers, which can be a downside for those seeking the most affordable option for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Limited Nationwide Presence: Farmers may have limited coverage options in certain regions, which could affect availability and service for some customers seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

#6 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Unique Discounts

Pros

• Unique Discount Opportunities: Liberty Mutual offers a range of unique discounts, such as for hybrid vehicles and newly married couples, which can contribute to securing the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance at a lower rate, which you can check out in our Liberty Mutual review.
• 24/7 Claims Support: Liberty Mutual offers around-the-clock claims support, ensuring that help is available whenever needed, which is crucial for those seeking reliable service for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Enhanced Digital Capabilities: With strong online tools and a user-friendly mobile app, Liberty Mutual makes it easy to manage policies and file claims, which is beneficial for those who prefer managing their insurance digitally while securing the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Cons

• Elevated Rates for Specific Risk Profiles: Certain demographics, such as those with less-than-perfect driving records, may face higher rates with Liberty Mutual, which could be a drawback for those seeking the most budget-friendly option for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Complex Discount System: Liberty Mutual’s discount system can be complex, potentially making it difficult for customers to fully understand and maximize their savings, which might affect the overall value of the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#7 – Nationwide: Best for Policy Discounts

Pros

• Wide-Ranging Coverage Choices: Nationwide offers a wide range of coverage options, including pet injury coverage and roadside assistance, providing comprehensive protection for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Strong Discounts: Nationwide provides various discounts, such as multi-vehicle and safe driver discounts, which can help reduce overall premiums for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance. Get more insights in our Nationwide review.
• Personalized Coverage Solutions: Nationwide’s policies are highly customizable, allowing policyholders to adjust coverage levels and add-ons to fit their specific needs, making it a flexible option for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Cons

• Greater Premiums for Specific Drivers: Nationwide may have higher rates for drivers with certain risk factors, such as a history of accidents, which could be a concern for those seeking the most affordable best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Inconsistent Customer Service: While Nationwide generally has a good reputation, some customers report inconsistencies in customer service quality, which can impact the experience of those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

#8 – Travelers:  Best for Customizable Plans

Pros

• All-Inclusive Protection: Travelers offers highly customizable insurance plans, including options for bundling and additional coverages. This flexibility is ideal for securing the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance tailored to specific needs. Policyholders can adjust coverage levels and endorsements to match their unique requirements.
• Discounts for Safe Driving: Travelers provides multiple discounts for safe driving, including their IntelliDrive program, which tracks driving habits and rewards good behavior. This can significantly reduce premiums for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance with a focus on safe driving practices.
• Innovative Coverage Add-Ons: With unique add-ons like equipment breakdown and custom parts coverage, Travelers offers enhanced protection options that cater to a wide range of needs, making it a competitive choice for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance. See more specifics in our Travelers auto insurance review.

Cons

• Limited Local Agents: Travelers may have fewer local agents compared to some competitors, potentially affecting access to personalized service for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Augmented Rates for High-Risk Categories: Some drivers, particularly those with a history of claims or poor credit, may find Travelers’ rates higher than other providers, which could impact affordability for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

#9 – American Family: Best for Personalized Service

Pros

• Personalized Service: American Family offers a high level of personalized service with dedicated agents who work closely with clients to tailor coverage options. This commitment to customer service makes them a top contender for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance, especially for those who value personalized attention.
• Full-Spectrum Insurance Options: American Family provides a wide range of coverage options, including unique endorsements and add-ons such as accident forgiveness and rental car coverage. These options enhance the overall protection, making it a strong choice for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Strong Local Presence: With numerous local agents throughout Milwaukee, American Family offers easy access to in-person support and advice, which is beneficial for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance and preferring face-to-face interactions. Delve into more details in our American Family insurance review.

Cons

• Increased Premiums for Certain Drivers: American Family’s rates can be higher for drivers with specific risk factors, such as those with a history of claims or poor credit, which may affect affordability for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Complex Policy Options: Some customers may find American Family’s range of policy options and endorsements complex, potentially making it challenging to select the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance coverage without thorough comparison and understanding.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#10 – Erie: Best for Local Expertise

Pros

• Local Expertise: Erie is known for its local expertise and strong presence in the Milwaukee area, offering tailored coverage options and personalized service. This local focus contributes to its standing as a provider of the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Premier Client Satisfaction: Erie consistently receives high marks for customer satisfaction and claims handling, reflecting its commitment to providing reliable and responsive service for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance. Discover additional details in our review of Erie auto insurance.
• Versatile Insurance Solutions: Erie offers a range of flexible coverage options and add-ons, including custom vehicle coverage and rental reimbursement. These options allow for a customizable insurance experience, enhancing its appeal for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Cons

• Limited National Presence: Erie’s coverage may be limited in some areas outside the Midwest, which can be a drawback for those who move frequently or travel extensively, impacting their search for the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.
• Boosted Costs for Riskier Driver Groups: While Erie offers competitive rates, certain drivers with high-risk profiles may face higher premiums, potentially affecting its affordability for those seeking the best Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance.

Minimum Auto Insurance in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Milwaukee, Wisconsin mandates that drivers carry at least the state’s minimum auto insurance requirements to ensure financial responsibility in case of an accident.

Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Coverage Level & Provider

Specifically, the required coverage includes $25,000 for bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and a minimum of $10,000 for property damage liability.

Cheap Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance by Age, Gender, and Marital Status

Auto insurance rates in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, vary significantly based on factors like age, gender, and marital status.

For instance, single 17-year-olds face much higher premiums compared to older adults, with an average auto insurance rates by age showing that teen drivers can reach up to $1,214 monthly with Allstate, while seniors generally see lower costs, such as $145 monthly with State Farm.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Cheap Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance By Driving Record

Your driving record plays a crucial role in determining your auto insurance monthly rates in Milwaukee. Drivers with a clean record typically enjoy lower premiums, while a single accident or speeding violation can lead to higher costs, as reflected by increased rates from insurers like Allstate and Nationwide.

For those dealing with charges, understanding the DWI vs. DUI differences can explain also how it will impact your insurance rates, as these distinctions may influence the severity of the penalty and subsequent insurance adjustments.

Moreover, having a DUI or a poor credit history can further elevate your monthly rates, though some insurers, such as USAA and American Family, offer more competitive rates in these situations.

To find the most affordable options, it’s essential to compare rates across various demographics and driving histories.

The Cheapest Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance Companies

To find the cheapest auto insurance in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, comparing monthly rates from various providers is essential.

Among the top insurers, American Family stands out with the most competitive average monthly rate of $164, while USAA follows with a rate of $203, and State Farm’s rate is $265. Evaluating quotes from these cheapest auto insurance companies can help you secure the best deal.

On the higher end, Nationwide has the highest average monthly rate at $601. Evaluating these rates across different demographics can help pinpoint the most affordable options and ensure you get the best value for your auto insurance needs.

Factors that affect auto insurance rates in Milwaukee, Wisconsin?

Auto insurance rates in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, fluctuate significantly due to various local factors. The high incidence of vehicle theft, with 4,589 reported cases according to the FBI, raises questions such as “Does auto insurance cover vehicle theft?“.

This contributes to elevated premiums as insurers face increased claims. The types of auto insurance and local conditions play a crucial role in determining these rates.

Longer average commutes—around 24.4 minutes for Milwaukee drivers—also drive up costs, as extended time on the road can lead to more frequent accidents.

Additionally, Milwaukee’s traffic congestion, ranked 457th globally by Inrix, is one of the key factors that affect auto insurance rates. To find the most affordable options, it’s helpful to compare monthly rates across different demographics and coverage needs.

Compare the cheapest auto insurance companies in Milwaukee, Wisconsin across different categories to find the insurer offering the best monthly rates tailored to your personal needs and learn how to compare auto insurance quotes effectively.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Compare Milwaukee, Wisconsin Auto Insurance Quotes

To determine how Milwaukee rates compare with other cities, including Oshkosh and Green Bay, and understand the guide to auto insurance quotes comparison effectively, check how Milwaukee’s rates stack up against these benchmarks.

Before you buy Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance, make sure you have compared rates from multiple companies. Enter your ZIP code below to get free Milwaukee, Wisconsin auto insurance quotes.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption