Best Auto Insurance for Sports Cars in 2024 (Find the Top 10 Companies Here!)

You can find the best auto insurance for sports cars with Progressive, State Farm, and Allstate, thanks to their generous discounts and robust UBI programs.

Progressive is our top pick for the best sports car insurance. Aside from Progressive’s auto insurance discounts, it also has tools that help you manage your policy and find coverage options to meet your budget.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Auto Insurance for Sports Cars

Find the best sports car insurance options below. Then, enter your ZIP code into our free online tool to find the cheapest option for your sports car.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#1 – Progressive: Top Pick Overall

Pros

• Specialized Sports Car Insurance: Progressive offers coverage options like loan/lease pay-off and custom equipment coverage. Explore all your coverage options in our Progressive auto insurance review.
• Competitive Rates: It’s not usually the very cheapest option, but Progressive does offer cheap performance car insurance.
• Name Your Price Tool: If you need to stick to a budget, use Progressive’s Name Your Price tool. It lists coverage options based on how much you want to spend on your insurance.

Cons

• Unexpected Rate Increases: Progressive customers report unexpected rate increases, even though they changed nothing about their policies.
• Limited Discounts for Sports Cars: Progressive offers 13 discounts, but sports car owners may find it difficult to save.

#2 – State Farm: Best for Sports Car Collectors

Pros

• Multi-Car Discount: Among 13 discounts, State Farm offers a multi-car discount that can help sports car collectors save. See other discounts in our State Farm auto insurance review.
• Coverage Options: State Farm offers some of the best sports car insurance with excellent coverage options, like travel expense coverage.
• Strong Financial Ratings: State Farm has an A++ from A.M. Best, which means the company is financially strong.

Cons

• Higher Rates for Some Drivers: Drivers with bad credit will likely find lower rates at another company, whether they drive a sports or standard car.
• Limited UBI Availability: State Farm has a usage-based insurance program called Drive Safe & Save, but it’s not available in all 50 states.

#3 – Allstate: Best for Low Mileage Drivers

Pros

• Usage-Based Programs: Allstate offers two UBI programs – Drivewise and Milewise. If you need low-mileage sports car insurance, consider Milewise. Milewise is ideal for low-mileage drivers since you only pay for the miles you drive.
• Policy Customization Options: Get the best high-performance car insurance with Allstate’s add-ons, including options like new car replacement and extended vehicle care.
• Strong Claims Ratings: Allstate customers typically report feeling satisfied with the speed of the claims resolution process.

Cons

• Higher Rates: No matter where you live or what type of driver you are, Allstate sports car insurance costs more than most companies. See how much you might pay in our Allstate auto insurance review.
• Mixed Customer Reviews: Allstate is one of the largest car insurance companies in America, but it receives mixed customer reviews.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#4 – AAA: Best for Roadside Assistance

Pros

• Affordable Rates: You can find cheap insurance for sports cars from AAA, especially if you need sports car insurance for young drivers.
• Roadside Assistance Plans: AAA offers three roadside assistance plans with different price points. Explore each plan in our AAA auto insurance review.
• Membership Perks: When you sign up for AAA membership, you’ll get perks like hotel discounts and travel deals.

Cons

• Membership Fees: AAA members have to pay an annual fee, which increases the overall cost of insurance.
• Regional Availability Varies: AAA memberships are run by regional clubs. Coverage availability can vary between regions, so you’ll need to check what you can purchase.

#5 – Erie: Best Customer Service

Pros

• Excellent Customer Service: Erie focuses on giving drivers the best customer service experience possible. It consistently gets positive reviews from its policyholders.
• Low Rates: Find low-priced coverage from Erie, especially if you’re looking for cheap sports car insurance for young drivers.
• Generous Coverage Limits: Erie offers enough coverage to take care of any damage that might happen to your sports car, whether you’re driving on a public street or enjoying a track event.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Erie only serves 12 states with auto insurance. See if you can purchase an Erie policy in your state in our Erie auto insurance review.
• Fewer Discounts: Although it offers affordable insurance, Erie doesn’t offer as many discounts as its larger competitors.

#6 – Liberty Mutual: Best Add-on Options

Pros

• Customizable Sports Car Policies: Liberty Mutual offers a variety of customization options for sports cars, including better car replacement, gap insurance, and original parts replacement.
• Accident Forgiveness: Purchase accident forgiveness from Liberty Mutual to have your first at-fault accident forgiven.
• Multi-policy Discounts: Save on your Liberty Mutual auto insurance by bundling with a homeowners or renters policy. See other discount options in our Liberty Mutual auto insurance review.

Cons

• Average Rates: Liberty Mutual certainly isn’t the most expensive option, but it also doesn’t have the cheapest car insurance for sports cars.
• Limited Aftermarket Modification Coverage: If you make modifications to your sports car, it might be hard to find coverage for them with Liberty Mutual.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#7 – Nationwide: Best for Usage-Based Insurance

Pros

• Vanishing Deductible: Sign up for Nationwide’s Vanishing Deductible program to save up to $500 on your deductible. Learn how to save with the Vanishing Deductible in our Nationwide auto insurance review.
• On Your Side Review: Nationwide offers a policy review with an agent once a year to make sure the coverage you’ve purchased is still worth your money.
• Excellent Coverage Options: Buy add-on insurance for your sports car policy, such as better car replacement coverage.

Cons

• Not Available Everywhere: Nationwide sells performance car insurance in just 47 states.
• Limited Local Agents: If you want personalized help with your car insurance, Nationwide might not be the right choice. Some areas are underrepresented by Nationwide representatives.

#8 – Farmers: Best for Discount Options

Pros

• Ample Discounts: Farmers offers 23 discounts to help you find cheap high-performance car insurance. One of the most popular Farmers discounts is for bundling policies.
• Policy Customizations: There are tons of ways to customize your Farmers policy, like better car replacement, glass and windshield coverage, and accident forgiveness.
• Highly-Rated Mobile App: Farmers has a highly-rated mobile app that you can use to manage your policy and start claims. Learn more about the app in our Farmers auto insurance review.

Cons

• Less Competitive Rates: It can be difficult to find cheap car insurance for sports cars from Farmers as its rates typically match the national average.
• Limited Local Agents: Farmers offers a smaller network of representatives compared to its competitors.

#9 – Travelers: Best for Unique Coverage Options

Pros

• IntelliDrive: Save up to 30% with Travelers’ UBI program, IntelliDrive, for consistently practicing safe driving habits.
• Specialized Coverage for Sports Cars: Travelers offers excellent coverage options for sports car insurance – see your options in our Travelers auto insurance review.
• Strong Financial Stability: With an A.M. Best rating of A++, you don’t need to worry about your Travelers claims going unpaid.

Cons

• Limited Coverage for Performance Modifications: If you enjoy modifying your sports car for better performance, Travelers does not offer the best coverage for custom parts.
• Average Rates: While Travelers is sometimes one of the cheaper options for sports car insurance, it’s often one of the most expensive for drivers with bad credit scores or at-fault accidents.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#10 – American Family: Best for Costco Members

Pros

• Specialized Coverage: You can purchase extra coverage for your sports car policy from American Family, like accidental death and dismemberment coverage and gap insurance.
• Costco Policies: Costco auto insurance policies are written by CONNECT, which is owned by American Family. Learn more about Costco policies in our American Family auto insurance review.
• Excellent Customer Service: American Family receives excellent reviews for its customer service, with drivers praising the company for its claims resolution speed.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Unfortunately, American Family is only available in 19 states.
• Higher Premiums: If you need the cheapest coverage possible, American Family might not offer the cheapest sports car insurance quotes.

Sports Car Auto Insurance Rates

They may be fun to drive, but there’s an important question you need to answer before you hit the road — how much is sports car insurance?

Sports cars usually have higher insurance rates for a variety of reasons, including the following:

• Higher chances for accidents
• Drivers tend to drive faster
• Repair costs can be higher

Several other factors affect your auto insurance rates, but insurance providers are mainly concerned with reckless driving when it comes to sports cars. When you’re in the market for a new car, you’re probably considering its price, your monthly payment, and your ideal car.

You may not be thinking about the impact that the car will have on your insurance policy. An affordable insurance rate will not look the same after you purchase an expensive sports car because even the best annual rate could be much higher than what you currently pay for your auto policy. Check below to see average sports car insurance costs from our top companies.

Auto Insurance Monthly Rates for Sports Cars by Coverage Level

You should always consider auto insurance costs when shopping for a new car, whether new or used, so you can make a solid choice.

When determining your car’s total ownership cost, consider the vehicle, its maintenance needs, related excise taxes, and the yearly rate you’ll pay for coverage. Many factors can impact your auto insurance rate. It’s just about understanding the linkage.

Why Sports Car Insurance Is More Expensive

Sports car drivers are more likely to drive recklessly and fast, which leads to more of a chance of damage done to the owner’s vehicle, other drivers’ cars, and property damage. Not to mention the possibility of high medical bills in the event of bodily injury. You should also always remember that the price you pay for comprehensive insurance or collision insurance is going to be relative to the vehicle cost.

Auto insurance companies check your driving record as well. How much does a sports car raise your insurance if your driving record isn’t clean?

Even if you are a safe sports car driver with a clean driving record, you will still pay more for auto insurance than a standard vehicle.

However, they may take this into account when determining the cost of your auto insurance. The fact that you have a habit of driving safely even with a fast and powerful vehicle can mean discounts on your policy.

Let’s look at average annual rates based on your driving history to see just how accidents and tickets can raise your rates.

Sports Car Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Driving Record

Just one accident can raise your rates by roughly $80 a month. Now imagine that on top of the already higher rates for a sports car and you can see how easily your rates can skyrocket.

Sports cars with low insurance rates often have drivers with clean driving records and minimal traffic violations. However, low insurance rates for sports cars depend on many factors.

Sports cars are more likely to be stolen and vandalized. Comprehensive coverage, which covers theft and vandalism, will be more pricey than it would be for a less valuable or desirable vehicle.

Vehicle theft can cause significant damage. When a vehicle is found deserted by the thief, parts are usually broken or missing, and the interior may also need some attention.

Parts for sports cars can be costly, so auto insurance companies need to have a way to keep themselves protected against extremely high repair costs.

They protect themselves by requiring more for a sports car owner’s policy. Since insurance companies define a sports car differently, be sure to compare several options before choosing a policy.

Can I get multiple auto insurance quotes? Yes, you could end up saving yourself money by getting a quote from various insurance companies at once.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

What Makes a Car a Sports Car for Insurance Purposes

The car’s size can actually have a direct correlation with the annual insurance rate you can expect to pay. Drivers everywhere may ask, is a coupe a sports car? Is a Mini Cooper considered a sports car for insurance purposes? What is considered a sports car?

There is no set definition of what makes a sports car, which you’ll notice when you’re filling out quote request forms. They always ask what kind of vehicle you drive, but you won’t see the option to select a sports car or any other type.

Are two-seater cars cheaper to insure? When you are talking about a sports car or any smaller car, statistics have shown that these are likely to be driven faster than larger cars. This statistic makes them more likely to be involved in auto accidents, have traffic citations, and so on. All of these factors drive up the average cost of auto insurance coverage for these vehicles.

If the price tag scares you off or you’re someone who genuinely needs more affordable car insurance, a bigger car, such as an SUV or a minivan, is actually going to have lower rates.

Bigger cars have lower auto insurance rates because larger vehicles fare much better in accidents. The liability limit space may actually make the rate higher for these cars, as your liability could be higher due to increased damage caused by your car.

If you drive an expensive vehicle your rates can be considerably higher. Depending on the type of car you drive or the types of auto insurance coverage you need, you may be forced to move on from your current insurance carrier in favor of a specialty insurer.

How Insurance Carriers Decide if Your Vehicle Is a Sports Car

Is a Honda Accord coupe considered a sports car? Is a Dodge Challenger considered a sports car? Some models may be considered sports cars by one company and regular vehicles by another. The best auto insurance companies look at several items to determine which cars fall under the sports car classification.

What makes a car a sports car? Let’s take a look!

Make & Model

When you’re shopping for coverage, comparing auto insurance rates by vehicle make and model is a crucial step. A high-value vehicle may not be adequately protected under a standard auto insurance policy; this is also true if you own an exotic vehicle.

For vehicles with higher than average horsepower in the engine, the insurance company will likely need to check out the car specs to determine if your rates will increase in comparison to standard car insurance.

Number of Cylinders

In any case, a vehicle with eight cylinders will cost more to insure than one with four cylinders. This applies to other high-performance vehicles as well, as you can see by examining rates from the best auto insurance companies for supercars.

But sports cars usually have more cylinders because they are high-performance vehicles that typically have a significantly more powerful engine than the average vehicle.

Body Height & Weight

Insurance companies will also consider a vehicle’s height and weight. Sports cars are smaller and lighter than regular sedans, so they are quick and highly maneuverable.

Sports cars are usually coupe-style cars with two doors and are two-seater vehicles.

According to auto insurance companies’ definitions, there are several exceptions, such as the Aston Martin Rapide S and the Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat. These are fast cars with four doors and more than two seats that often require higher coverage and are usually classified as sports cars for insurance purposes.

Is the Dodge Charger a sports car on insurance? Yes. Are Ford Mustangs considered sports cars for insurance? Yes. Is a Camaro considered a sports car for insurance? Yes.

What about a Corvette, Challenger, Ferrari, Lamborghini, and Porsche? Yes. Those are easy. But here’s where it gets more complicated: What about a Mini Cooper? Or a Dodge Dart?

Is a Mitsubishi Eclipse considered a sports car for insurance? Is a Nissan Maxima considered a sports car? These are more difficult. If you own a Mitsubishi vehicle, it’s essential to research and select the most suitable cheap Mitsubishi auto insurance to safeguard your investment and drive with peace of mind.

The best way to get specific rate details is to compare quotes with the vehicle’s exact make and model.

Of course, the best way to find the lowest quotes is to learn how to evaluate auto insurance quotes. Skipping this crucial step means you likely overpay for your insurance.

How To Find the Cheapest Sports Car Auto Insurance

When you’re ready to learn how to get the best auto insurance, you might be surprised by the cost of sports car coverage. Even the least expensive sports cars to insure can come with high price tags. However, there are plenty of ways to save. Try the following tips to find the best sports car insurance rates:

• Find discounts. Most companies offer discounts to help you save. Popular options include bundling policies, being a safe driver, and signing up for paperless documents.
• Lower your coverage. Picking the least amount of coverage you need will lower your rates, but it also leaves your car without valuable protection.
• Raise your deductible. Your deductible is the portion you pay when you file a claim before your insurance kicks in. Choosing a higher deductible will lower your monthly premium, but it also means you’ll have to pay more if you file a claim.
• Keep your driving record clean. A simple way to keep your rates low is to avoid accident and traffic violations.

Of course, the best way to find the lowest rates is to compare quotes. Comparing quotes will help you find which company has the lowest rates for your sports car.

Now that we’ve seen how much more sports car auto insurance is, let’s talk about how to get those rates down. One way to keep your rates low is to look for any available auto insurance discounts. Keep reading to learn more about how to get your rates down.

Network With Other Sports Car Owners

This technique can help save on auto insurance as well. Start with the dealer or the person you purchased the car from. In the case of an individual, ask who their insurance provider was.

A dealer who sells high-end vehicles every week is almost sure to have a relationship with individual insurance companies.

Ask them whom they can recommend and if you are eligible for a “family and friends” discount. At the very least, it certainly cannot hurt to ask. You can also look for auto insurance company agents in your area to help.

Also, don’t overlook any local car clubs in your area that might be able to offer assistance.

Niche Markets for Sports Car Insurance

Some auto insurance companies specialize in providing insurance for antique, classic, or “muscle cars.” This smaller niche market allows for customized insurance for unique vehicles. It provides coverage for a given vehicle’s actual value, not just the standard “blue book” value for that particular year’s car.

This type of insurance allows the company and vehicle owner to set an “agreed value” for the car and its total replacement cost. Shopping at the best companies that offer agreed value can help you save. Usually, deductibles can also be tailored to help manage costs.

A Defensive Driving Class Helps Lower Your Auto Insurance Rates

Wondering why you need to take a defensive driving class? This is a surefire way to help lower auto insurance costs. The average insurance company will allow for up to a 10% discount on the liability portion of your auto insurance.

Typically, these courses are offered as a six-hour session, and some insurers even offer them online. The registration fee for this course will pay for itself in no time.

Sports Car Auto Insurance Discounts

Before buying your dream car, a sit-down meeting with your current insurance agent would be a wise choice. Typically, there are several auto insurance discounts available through your current provider if you look for them and inquire about them.

Sports car drivers may be eligible for a variety of discounts. Check below to see popular sports car discounts from our top companies.

According to the National Safety Council, discounts are available for combining policies, car safety features, or having a good driving record.

One or two moving violations can quickly add up to a few points on your license and result in increased rates.

Other discounts to look for are low annual mileage discounts, good student discounts, or automatic drafts from your checking account that can earn you a discount.

Installation of an anti-theft device and alarm systems can put money back in your pocket as well.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

The Cheapest Insurance Sports Cars

How much is insurance for a high-end sports car? The high-end sports cars available on the market will carry the highest rate amounts. Finding fast cars with cheap insurance can be challenging, but there’s an easy rule to follow — the cheapest sports cars to insure are also the least expensive cars.

When you are talking about a sports car, you are probably talking about a vehicle that has a very high MSRP.

The MSRP, the higher it goes, will also cause the auto insurance rate to go up. The higher rate is due to the car needing to be covered fully for its value should something happen to it.

Just to give you an idea of what auto insurance will cost, let’s look at the rates for the cheapest sports cars to insure.

Sports Car Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Model

If you total a sports car, your insurance company will pay more than average to replace it. Therefore, increasing your insurance limits so that you are repaid in the event of a loss will increase your auto insurance rates.

Think about things such as the motor that is in your sports car. More horsepower under the hood of your car tells the insurance companies out there that you’re going to drive at a faster speed than someone in a small four-cylinder compact ride.

The auto insurance rate will reflect the insurance company’s thought process and will be higher as a result.

The car you drive will have a direct impact on the rate you pay to insure it. When you are talking about a sports car, you have to think about the higher likelihood that you present to an insurer for driving fast, recklessly, or even recreationally. If you get traffic violations while driving a sports car, you may need high-risk auto insurance, which costs even more.

Due to this increased risk, the auto insurance rate will have to be increased to cover the exposure you present. Additionally, there are non-driving factors that affect your auto insurance rates, like age and credit score. Be sure to make price comparisons, as some insurers will be able to offer lower rates to cover your sports car than others.

How Age Affects Sports Car Auto Insurance

Insurance on sports cars for young drivers can be extremely expensive. Auto insurance on a sports car for teen drivers and young adults is close to the cost of high-risk drivers. When you factor in the value and performance of a sports car or exotic car, auto insurance rates can increase by thousands.

The younger you are, the higher the auto insurance on sports cars. Therefore, sports car auto insurance for 18-year-old drivers would be more expensive than for a 21-year-old driver who owns a sports car.

The cheapest insurance companies are usually Geico, Progressive, and USAA.

Auto insurance for sports cars for drivers under 25 years old can cost up to $3,000 per year for liability-only insurance and up to $12,000 per year for full coverage.

Take a look at the table below to compare sports car insurance rates by age.

Sports Car Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Age

As you can see, sports car insurance costs under 25 years old can be very pricy compared to older adults. Finding the best auto insurance for young adults can be challenging, but it’s possible with a little research.

What to Consider When Buying Insurance for Sports Cars

Many factors are at play when you figure out how to get auto insurance. We’ve already discussed how the type of car you drive and your driving record affect your rates.

Other factors like your age, credit score, where you live, and even your gender will impact your rates as well.

🐎Are you buying a new sports car?⏩The best providers for sports cars might surprise you! Check out rates from Geico, Nationwide, and other top providers in your area on our site: https://t.co/27f1xf131D.🔥 Learn more about sports car insurance: https://t.co/aImMPd891k pic.twitter.com/Sd3fkIXuIL

— AutoInsurance.org (@AutoInsurance) March 28, 2023

Not all companies will charge the same rates based on all of those factors. In fact, in some states, companies can’t even consider your gender or credit score when writing a policy.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

How to Find the Best Auto Insurance Companies for Sports Cars

If you want to buy car insurance from the best car insurance companies for sports cars, you don’t have to compromise quality in coverage for the cost. Some of the best auto insurance companies in the nation can cover your sports car based on the make and model.

Look into opportunities to bundle and stack discounts, especially if you’re a young driver with high rates. Safety discounts may be your best bet, especially if your sports car comes equipped with anti-lock brakes and passive restraints.

Calling all drivers under 25!📢Do insurance costs seem crazy high?😱Well, your age can actually have a massive effect on your coverage costs! https://t.co/27f1xf131D want to help you understand why young drivers pay these higher prices!💲Learn more here👉: https://t.co/J43PJYIyTo pic.twitter.com/PlNFKAO54N

— AutoInsurance.org (@AutoInsurance) May 22, 2023

Do shop around and ask for quotes, even from local car insurance companies. You might find one of the cheapest auto insurance companies for your sports cars in surprising places.

Find the Best Auto Insurance for Sports Cars Today

This technique is probably a given in our wired society today. Several websites are available to help consumers shop for coverage, whether you want minimum or full coverage auto insurance. From the comfort of your home, you can compare quotes from dozens of different insurance companies quite easily. Most of these online tools will allow you to customize your information to match your particular situation.

Looking to compare monthly vs. annual rates? One can compare possible savings almost instantly and buy auto insurance for sports cars just as quickly. Find affordable sports car auto insurance rates near you with our free comparison tool. Enter your ZIP code to start getting quotes and find affordable sports car auto insurance near you today.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption